Even more shocking, the smiling woman in the photo is a veterinarian, and the cat she killed might have been her neighbors' pet – not a feral cat as she suggested. Dr. Kristen Lindsey's post has set off a storm of controversy, with many demanding that Lindsey be stripped of her vet's license and criminally charged for the cat's death.
Lindsey, 31, posted the picture to her page (her account has since been deactivated) last Wednesday night with the comment, "My first bow kill, lol. The only good feral tomcat is one with an arrow through it's [sic] head! Vet of the year award ... Gladly accepted."
Earlier that day, a couple living nearby in Brenham, Texas, reported that their six-year-old orange tabby, Tiger, was missing.
"In the photos (on Lindsey's page and of Tiger), they appear to be identical," Elizabeth Holtz of Alley Cat Allies, a cat-protection advocacy organization working on the case, tells PEOPLE.
"We are positive that it's Tiger," Melanie DeAeth, president of True Blue Animal Rescue, which is working with Tiger's owners to start a fund for feral-cat education, tells PEOPLE.
"We matched up the markings with some very distinct markings that Tiger had and they are exactly the same. In addition, Tiger always came home for dinner until the day the picture was posted. His bowl has remained untouched since this happened."
After the picture went viral, Lindsey was fired from her job at Washington Animal Clinic in Brenham. Additionally, the Austin County Sheriff's Office investigated and turned over the case for filing of charges of cruelty to animals, a misdemeanor.
The case is still under review and no criminal charges had been filed as of Thursday morning, the Austin County District Attorney's office told PEOPLE. Lindsey could not be reached for comment.
The Texas Veterinary Medical Association condemned Lindsey's actions, saying she violated a vet's oath to protect animals. Even if feral cats, which live outdoors and shy away from human interaction, are to be euthanized, it should be done via injection with sodium pentobarbital, "the only legal method of euthanizing a dog or cat in an animal shelter in Texas," said Dr. Katie Luke Broaddus, chief veterinarian of the Austin, Texas, Humane Society.
The organization and other animal groups advocate instead that feral cats be trapped, neutered and then returned to the outdoors, she said.
Meanwhile, the Texas State Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners tells PEOPLE it can't confirm if an investigation is underway but says the punishment for a vet convicted of animal cruelty can range from a reprimand to license suspension or revocation.
http://www.peoplepets.com/people/pets/article/0,,20918066,00.html